Finally a study that gets it right, at least from my experience. I feel that any person, be them male or female, emerges from a failed relationship is damaged. At least anyone with a heart. I do agree that men are more reluctant to marry but I feel that has more to do with fear of closing off options than mental status. We grow up as little girls believing that one day prince charming is going to show up on his white stallion and we’ll ride off into the sunset to our happily ever after. Well girls, there is no happily ever after; there is just life. Life is work, devotion, arguments, bills, and sometimes going to bed angry. Once we accept the reality of what a relationship is we can help to calm the anxiety the men in our lives feel as a result of our unfair expectations. As for men, you have to understand that marriage isn’t just a contract where you sign over your life and soul. It is a celebration of love and commitment. We don’t want to be married, we want to be your wife. We want to love, honor, and (yes I still believe this) obey you. We want you to do the same. It’s not about owning a person; it’s about two people owning each others hearts. (Just a note about The guy I am about to write about we broke up not too long ago but I still feel this relationship is not over, prime example he is asleep in the recliner right next to me. The physical aspect of our relationship has change but everything else has remained the sane) I have lived with D for a year and a half and I don’t love him any less than if he were my husband but I yearn to belong to him in every sense; legally, in the eyes of God, and I would be beyond honored to take his name. He on the other hand feels that living together in the way we do we are married in every sense other than a piece of paper.
“Reference: Partnership and mental health over time. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 2004:58; 53-8
Cohabiting Better For Men’s Mental Health; Marriage Better For Women’s
Jan 05 2004
Getting back into a relationship after a marriage fails is good for men’s mental health, but bad for women’s, suggest the results of national survey in the U.K. The study also found that cohabiting is better for men’s mental health, but marriage is better for women’s,.
The research is based on responses to a validated mental health questionnaire from 4,430 men and women under the age of 65, part of the annual British Household Panel Survey, which began in 1991. Men whose relationships with a first partner fell apart had much poorer mental health than men who remained with their first partner. And those who decided to live with a new partner after a marriage break-up also had better mental health than men who stayed single or who remarried.
The mental health of women who had not split up from their partners was also better than that of women who did. But women’s mental health progressively deteriorated the more break-ups they experienced and the more times they moved on to other relationships. Women who stayed single actually enjoyed much better mental health, which was not true of men.
While the mental health of both men and women was better in long term relationships. Men who chose to marry their partners fared had poorer mental health than those who chose just to live with them. Women fared better if they married.
The authors conclude that living with a partner is better for mental health, but that women have a harder time emotionally when relationships fail.”
